Naturally, internet sleuths immediately got to work, pouring over the evidence and rounding up clues.

“The spot is a mark from an IV, so he’s likely a starter,” @FootballGirlAna theorized. “It’s on his right hand. That plus the legs being crossed to the left, I’d guess he’s left handed. The leg hair is very light. He’s probably blonde/ginger. JS is 6’0 and size 11M shoe so I would guess he’s slightly taller & has a bigger foot.”

Star later gave further hints from Casper, Wyoming, sharing a picture of the boyfriend with his back to the camera and saying that “His team didn’t make it to the #SuperBowl but he’s 6’6” and plays perfect in the bedroom.”

More people got to work with this further information, listing all the teams with orange in their colors just because the guy was wearing orange, and checking the heights of various players.

Considering there’s only one out football player currently in the NFL — Carl Nassib, who is in a relationship — the whole situation also seems a little strange. Is Star really dating an NFL player? Is that NFL player doing a soft launch of his coming out through the extremely controversial makeup guru’s social media? Or is this all just some weird ploy from Star to make his comeback?

Presumably we’ll find out one way or another eventually, but people on the internet love a good mystery, and will undoubtedly keep trying to solve it for themselves in the meantime.