Fan-Casting An All-Winners Season 2 of 'RuPaul's Drag Race All Stars'

Did someone say All-Winners season 2?

In 2022, Mama Ru held the first-ever all-winners edition of RuPaul’s Drag Race All Stars, which brought back queens like Raja, Jinkx Monsoon, Yvie Oddly, Jaida Essence Hall, Monét X Change, Trinity The Tuck, Shea Couleé, and The Vivienne.

Despite being another installment in the All Stars series, All Stars 7 was a very legendary legend season that featured Drag Race winners as contestants and followed a brand-new format that didn’t include any eliminations. Though some fans have preferences for other seasons, many viewers hailed All Stars 7 as the best season of Drag Race of all time.

As a result, it didn’t take long for fans to start speculating when a second all-winners season of Drag Race will take place, and which queens would be featured in that new installment. While we don’t believe that another all-winners season is happening right away, it’s time to do some fan-casting of past winners that we’d love to see competing for another crown!

Scroll through to check out our fan-casting for a second all-winners edition of RuPaul’s Drag Race All Stars, which is available for streaming on Paramount+.

Bob The Drag Queen (Season 8)

We were gagged that Bob The Drag Queen wasn’t cast in the first all-winners season of Drag Race, so we are absolutely hoping that she will be included in a second winners edition. The season eight winner is one of the most popular and successful Drag Race winners of all time, so seeing her enter this competition again would be an absolute blast.

Alaska (All Stars 2)

Alaska is widely considered the ultimate RuGirls in terms of Drag Race references and knowledge. A lot of fans also consider All Stars 2 the best season of Drag Race. All things considered, it would be incredibly entertaining to watch Alaska vying for a second crown during an all-winners season.

Sasha Velour (Season 9)

While many Drag Race fans felt like Sasha Velour would never return to compete in an all-winners edition of the show, the season nine winner recently said in a few interviews that she would absolutely welcome the idea. After seeing what Sasha is capable of throughout season nine, as well as her out-of-this-world lip sync performances from the grand finale, the idea of casting her in an all-winners season is very exciting.

Aquaria (Season 10)

The crowning of Aquaria in season 10 was very exciting given that she was simultaneously pushing the show forward while also being incredibly reverential of the series as a whole. She has admitted many times that Drag Race played a huge influence in her career, which made her crowning feel extra special. After glowing up even further over the years, Aquaria would be an exciting contender for another legendary legend All Stars.

Symone (Season 13)

Symone absolutely steamrolled the competition in season 13 despite being in a cast with several other heavy-hitters. It would be really fascinating to see what Symone could do in an all-winners season, and to witness just how much her career has evolved as she travels the world and takes over the fashion industry.

Kylie Sonique Love (All Stars 6)

From being an early-out queen in season two to winning All Stars 6, Kylie Sonique Love has had one of the most amazing Ru-demption journeys in the history of Drag Race. As a fully realized trans woman and drag entertainer, we would really love to see Kylie coming back for a second edition of all-winners so that she build an even bigger legacy in the franchise.

Lawrence Chaney (RuPaul’s Drag Race UK Season 2)

The inclusion of Drag Race UK season one winner The Vivienne on All Stars 7 was really exciting, so it’s only right that we keep that trend going by casting Lawrence Chaney, the winner of season two, in a subsequent all-winners season. Given how charismatic and hilarious Lawrence is, it would also make the season even more entertaining and competitive.

Priyanka (Canada’s Drag Race Season 1)

Speaking of international Drag Race champions, we’d be obsessed to see Priyanka competing in a second all-winners season of All Stars. This feels even more timely now that Jimbo has become the first-ever international contestant to enter the Drag Race Hall of Fame. Canada representation on all-winners? Yes, please!