• Log in
    Brand Logo
    #Celebs#Geek#TV#Movies#Music#ComingOut#Love&Sex#FirstPerson#Activism#Video
    ADVOCATEOUTOUT TRAVELERPLUS
    SubscribeSubscriber ServicesEmail Newsletter Signup
    CONTACTCAREER OPPORTUNITIESADVERTISE WITH USPRIVACY POLICYPRIVACY PREFERENCESTERMS OF USELEGAL NOTICE
    © 2023 Pride Publishing Inc.
    All Rights reserved
    OUTOUT
    Scroll To Top

    By continuing to use our site, you agree to our Private Policy and Terms of Use.

    Accept

    7 Reasons the Phrase “Gold Star Lesbian” Needs to Die

    Cassie SheetsAndrew J. Stillman
    | 08/01/23

    7 Reasons the Phrase “Gold Star Lesbian” Needs to Die


    What’s the gold star for?

    7 Reasons the Phrase \u201cGold Star Lesbian\u201d Needs to Die

    Shutterstock

    Simply put, a “gold star lesbian” is a lesbian who has never slept with a man. So, what’s the problem? Why does this phrase need to die? Take a look at the following seven reasons.

    1. It's another attempt to control women

    two men holding a pride rainbow

    Shutterstock

    Although some lesbians wear the term with pride, a lot also feel like it’s offensive. The current climate already aims to control women’s reproductive systems, and the “gold star” term has a subtle connotation that women “need” to sleep with at least one man during their lifetime, lest they miss out on a “necessary” experience. This isn’t even to touch on the experiences of those who have had sex against their will, but we’ll get to that in a moment.

    2. It reinforces negative LGBTQIA+ stereotypes

    two women sharing a kiss and cuddle

    Shutterstock

    The “gold star” term also reinforces the idea that anyone on the LGBTQ+ spectrum can “choose” who they would like to have sex with. By asking “why” they haven’t had sex with the opposite gender, it insinuates they have a desire they’re simply not acting on, and that’s simply not the truth.

    3. It places value on some sexual experiences above others.

    two women laughing

    Shutterstock

    Most of us can probably agree that it’s totally weird and creepy to place a huge amount of value on the virginity of women and girls (virginity meaning, typically, penis-in-vagina hetero sex), because women don’t lose value when they “lose” their virginity. The whole “gold star lesbian” thing places those same values of “purity” on lesbians who haven’t slept with men. A woman’s value shouldn’t have anything to do with whom she has or hasn’t slept with, regardless of what community she’s in.

    4. There are plenty of lesbians who have slept with men…and guess what? They’re still lesbians.

    two women kissing on a beach

    Shutterstock

    We live in a messed up heteronormative world that puts enormous pressure on women to partner up with men, and some lesbians do just that before they come out. It doesn’t change the fact that those lesbians are still only attracted to women, and we shouldn’t imply their sexuality is less legitimate, or that their attraction to women is any less pure.

    5. It plays into the narrative that bi women have less pure intentions when they date women.

    lesbians enjoying each others company

    Shutterstock

    The idea that never sleeping with a man is the standard we should all strive to live up to plays into the idea that bisexual women are less desirable for lesbians to date, since they’re not as “pure” in their sexual desires or experiences.

    6. It can make it more difficult for rape survivors to talk about their experiences.

    two women enjoying each other

    Shutterstock

    Placing so much value on the “gold star” can make lesbians who have never had sex with men, but who have been raped by men, feel far more uncomfortable talking about their experience with other lesbians, because the “gold star” is so tied into ideas of status and purity.

    7. It can be used to justify transphobia.

    lesbians hugging and smiling

    Shutterstock

    While “gold star lesbian” really just means a lesbian who has never slept with a man, penis is often equated with man in lesbian communities, and invoking the “gross out” effect of certain genitalia in “gold star” conversations is common. (We see it played for humor in online videos where lesbians touch a penis for the first time.) Here’s the thing: no one really cares what genitalia your girlfriend has, and no one really cares who you date. But don’t exclude trans lesbians, or the cis lesbians who date them from your definition of “ideal” or “real” lesbians.

    Latest Stories

    Ongina; Katya; LaLa Ri
    DragQueens
    Badge
    gallery

    'RuPaul's Drag Race' Queens Eliminated After Winning A Challenge

    18m
    Alyson Stoner, Jojo Siwa, Garrett Clayton
    Celebrities
    Badge
    gallery

    9 LGBTQ+ Stars You Didn't Know Got Their Start on Nickelodeon

    42m
    UPDATED: 92 LGBTQ+ Movies We Can’t Wait To See In 2023
    Movies
    Badge
    gallery

    UPDATED: 87 LGBTQ+ Movies We Can’t Wait To See In 2023

    44m
    20 Steamy Pics of Figure Skater Wesley Campbell That'll Make Ice Melt
    Celebrities
    Badge
    gallery

    20 Steamy Pics of Figure Skater Wesley Campbell That'll Make Ice Melt

    57m
    The 13 Best & Most Empowering Things About Being Bisexual
    Identities
    Badge
    gallery

    The 13 Best & Most Empowering Things About Being Bisexual

    7h
    Mathew Scott Montgomery, Raven-Symoné and Haley Kiyoko
    Celebrities
    Badge
    gallery

    22 Former Disney Stars Who Have Come Out As LGBTQ+

    23h
    La Cruz
    Celebrities
    Badge
    gallery

    15 Steamy Pics Of Out Gay Reggaeton Star La Cruz

    September 20 2023 3:27 PM
    15 Things Every Grindr Host Should Have Ready to Go
    Sex
    Badge
    gallery

    15 Things Every Grindr Host Should Have Ready to Go

    September 20 2023 11:30 AM
    27 TV Shows With Bisexual Guy Characters
    TV
    Badge
    gallery

    27 TV Shows With Bisexual Guy Characters

    September 20 2023 10:38 AM
    Mexican men on Instagram
    Men
    Badge
    gallery

    15 Mexican Hunks You Need To Follow On Instagram

    September 19 2023 5:06 PM
    Bob the Drag Queen and Monet X Change; Trixie Mattel and Katya; Kim Chi and Naomi Smalls
    DragQueens
    Badge
    gallery

    Fan-Casting An All-BFFs Season of 'RuPaul's Drag Race All Stars'

    September 19 2023 3:45 PM
    10 Signs That You Might Be Bisexual
    Bisexual
    Badge
    gallery

    10 Signs That You Might Be Bisexual

    September 19 2023 12:35 PM
    Books with bisexual characters
    Books
    Badge
    gallery

    5 Bi Authors & 5 Books Featuring Bi Characters That You Should Read

    September 19 2023 12:00 PM
    bisexual anthems
    Music
    Badge
    gallery

    30 Pop Anthems About Bisexuality

    September 19 2023 9:10 AM
    Katya; Bob the Drag Queen; Kahmora Hall
    DragQueens
    Badge
    gallery

    'RuPaul's Drag Race' Queens Who Had Different Names Before The Show

    September 18 2023 2:48 PM
    Ricky Martin; Zane Phillips; Luke Evans
    Celebrities
    Badge
    gallery

    These Celebs Are Sharing Steamy Thirst Traps Like Summer Never Ended

    September 18 2023 2:46 PM
    100 Lesbian Things To Do Before You Die
    Lesbian
    Badge
    gallery

    100 Lesbian Things To Do Before You Die

    September 18 2023 1:41 PM
    (R to L) Cary Grant, Josephine Baker, and Frida Kahlo
    BiWeek
    Badge
    gallery

    15 Historical Icons You Didn't Know Were Bisexual

    September 18 2023 9:00 AM
    9 Questions About Nose Jobs You Want to Know (But Are Afraid to Ask)
    Health
    Badge
    gallery

    9 Questions About Nose Jobs You Want to Know (But Are Afraid to Ask)

    September 17 2023 8:05 AM
    Colombian Hotties on Instagram
    Men
    Badge
    gallery

    15 Colombian Hotties You Need To Follow On Instagram

    September 15 2023 4:01 PM

    Trending Stories

    'American Idol' Season 1 OG Jim Verraros Is Ready to Take His Bow

    Vivek Ramaswamy's Wife Doesn't Agree With His COVID Opinion

    Jann Wenner's Legacy: Janis Joplin Lamented Rolling Stone Story Days Before Death

    Why Migrant Crossings at the Southern Border Are on the Rise

    Kevin Aviance DJs Launch of Zcrave’s New F3TISH Collection

    Plus156 Sept/Oct: Our Annual Latinx Issue

    Missouri Transgender Girl Wins Homecoming Queen and the Right Loses It

    This HIV Ally Is Spicing Up Sexual Health

    30th Annual Long Beach Qfilms Festival Features ‘Big Boys’ This Weekend

    Meet Layton Williams & Nikita Kuzmin, 'Strictly's New Same-Sex Dance Couple

    Matt Bomer Orders Jonathan Bailey Around in Steamy 'Fellow Travelers' Clip

    Las Vegas Brings The Fright With Provocative New Show 'Abandon'

    Kween Kong's 'Drag Race Down Under' S3 Finale Choreo Was Scrapped

    What Does It Mean to Be Bisexual?

    Wednesday's Top Stories: GOP Infighting, Migrant Influx, Economic Concerns

    Here’s Why So Many Visitors Yearn to Stay on This Secret Caribbean Island

    Kim Petras Is Surprise Releasing Her Scrapped 1st Album 'Problematique'

    Arrests Follow HIV Funding Protest at Speaker McCarthy's Office

    Elijah McClain Died From a Ketamine Injection During a Police Stop. Finally, 2 Officers Face Trial

    Kanye West ‘Didn’t Mean What he Said’ About Jews, Adidas CEO Says

    Lauren Boebert Dumps Theater Date, Sidesteps Fondling Incident Questions

    6 Great American Road Trips Perfect for Fall Colors

    Meet Two Amazing Activists Speaking Up About Black Women and HIV

    Este Aliado del VIH Está Condimentando la Salud Sexual

    John Waters Finally Gets Star on Hollywood Walk of Fame and His Due

    Most Recent

    DACA Immigration Policy Ruled Unlawful, But Allowed to Continue

    George W. Bush Calls Out Republicans Trying to End HIV Program PEPFAR

    Dixon Dallas Gets Candid on Rising Stardom, Handling Critics, and Sexuality

    Dixon Dallas Is Back With Another Raunchy, Catchy Gay Country Song

    Kanye West ‘Didn’t Mean What he Said’ About Jews, Adidas CEO Says

    Stewart Taylor Releases New Breakup Anthem "Favorite Ex"

    Canada Has Some of the Highest Mpox Rates in the World

    Travis Scott Investigated For Assault and $12,000 in Property Damage

    Vivek Ramaswamy's Wife Doesn't Agree With His COVID Opinion

    Art Exhibit Explores Code-Switching Through a Queer Modern Lens

    Lauren Boebert's 'Rude, Disruptive' Behavior Isn't Surprising, Says Local News Anchor

    How to Honor Senior Survivors of HIV

    Grace Van Dien, Stranger Things Actor, Says She's Turning Down Roles Over Sexual Harassment

    Dr. Randa Jaafar on Her New Practice & Helping Women Feel Their Best

    These 'Red, White & Royal Blue' Bloopers Will Make You Crack a Rib From Laughing

    Get Ready for Provincetown’s Third-Annual Washashore Festival Featuring a Rising Tide of Queer Musical Talent

    Lisa Rinna Does PTown

    New 'Drag Race' Host Is a Legendary Activist Living With HIV

    Batman Book Author Scolded for Saying 'Gay' in Georgia School District

    HIV Warrior Ronnie Grace Battling Stage 4 Cancer

    Elijah McClain Died From a Ketamine Injection During a Police Stop. Finally, 2 Officers Face Trial

    SF Leather Week Opens with Inauguration of World’s First Leather and Queer History Public Space

    Must-Visit Design Hotspots for LGBTQ+ Travelers in Cool Tokyo

    Pentagon Says It'll Review Cases of LGBTQ+ Vets Who Were Denied Honorable Discharges: Report

    Recommended Stories for You

    DACA Immigration Policy Ruled Unlawful, But Allowed to Continue

    George W. Bush Calls Out Republicans Trying to End HIV Program PEPFAR

    Dixon Dallas Gets Candid on Rising Stardom, Handling Critics, and Sexuality

    Dixon Dallas Is Back With Another Raunchy, Catchy Gay Country Song

    Kanye West ‘Didn’t Mean What he Said’ About Jews, Adidas CEO Says

    Stewart Taylor Releases New Breakup Anthem "Favorite Ex"

    Canada Has Some of the Highest Mpox Rates in the World

    Travis Scott Investigated For Assault and $12,000 in Property Damage

    Vivek Ramaswamy's Wife Doesn't Agree With His COVID Opinion

    Art Exhibit Explores Code-Switching Through a Queer Modern Lens

    Lauren Boebert's 'Rude, Disruptive' Behavior Isn't Surprising, Says Local News Anchor

    How to Honor Senior Survivors of HIV

    Grace Van Dien, Stranger Things Actor, Says She's Turning Down Roles Over Sexual Harassment

    Dr. Randa Jaafar on Her New Practice & Helping Women Feel Their Best

    These 'Red, White & Royal Blue' Bloopers Will Make You Crack a Rib From Laughing

    Get Ready for Provincetown’s Third-Annual Washashore Festival Featuring a Rising Tide of Queer Musical Talent

    Lisa Rinna Does PTown

    New 'Drag Race' Host Is a Legendary Activist Living With HIV

    Batman Book Author Scolded for Saying 'Gay' in Georgia School District

    HIV Warrior Ronnie Grace Battling Stage 4 Cancer

    Elijah McClain Died From a Ketamine Injection During a Police Stop. Finally, 2 Officers Face Trial

    SF Leather Week Opens with Inauguration of World’s First Leather and Queer History Public Space

    Must-Visit Design Hotspots for LGBTQ+ Travelers in Cool Tokyo

    Pentagon Says It'll Review Cases of LGBTQ+ Vets Who Were Denied Honorable Discharges: Report